Sunday 24 April 2016

Preventing the need for ATUs by enabling #ordinarylives


#7Daysofaction started on Monday 18th April 2016.  The campaign has been launched by the mothers and family members of people with learning disabilities (and often, autism) who are currently trapped in Assessment & Treatment Units (ATUs).

These people have committed no crime but in many cases they are treated worse than criminals. Some have died as a result of neglect and poor care in state funded institutions.  Most have not been diagnosed with a mental health condition, yet are detained under the Mental Health Act and they remain in Units for years at a time.
There are currently 3000 people in ATUs and the average cost of being kept in an ATU is £3500 per week…..yes, per week.  That’s your tax spondulas right there.  All these detained folk want is to be living back home with their families or living in their own homes with support.  They just want an #ordinarylife.

In this blogpost, I want to look at why young people end up in ATUs and what can be done to prevent this happening.

What triggers the crisis?

Here Jan Walmsley observes that ‘Frequently, as young people with autism and complex needs get into their teens, not only do they struggle with the changes associated with adolescence, they also begin to face the truth that their lives will not be like those of their siblings. They will not leave school, get a job, go away to Uni or College, they are unlikely to get a girl or boyfriend, their lives will probably be sheltered and limited. There is a reaction, a change in behaviour, often violence or depression.’

Let’s look at some of those key phrases:

  • Begin to face the truth
  • Not like the lives of their siblings
  • Won’t get a job
  • Won’t go to college or Uni
  • Unlikely to get a girlfriend or boyfriend
  • Sheltered and limited lives

Yep, I too would do my nut if I felt that that was what was ahead of me. And so would you.  A reaction, a change in behaviour, is a perfectly natural human response to this kind of coming of age crisis.

And meanwhile, what’s going through our heads in parallel parenting universe is something like ‘What will happen to him when I die?  How will he cope? Who will look after him? Who will love him?’  Some of us know, in the darkest depths of our souls, that when we die, if the system hasn’t changed, our beloved young people will end up in institutions.  Can we rely on the system changing?

Let’s go back to those bullet pointed phrases and dig a bit deeper.

‘Begin to face the truth’………….'not like the lives of their siblings’………..the young person, perhaps, is only just starting to realise this but the supporting services (health, education and social care) have known it was coming for a long time.  

‘Won’t get a job’………..'won’t go to college or Uni’………'unlikely to get a girlfriend or boyfriend’………..'sheltered and limited lives’……..*cringe*, *sob* 

Why do services only talk about ‘transition’ at 16 or 18 when they could have been supporting that young person from a very early age to develop the competencies and capacities we all need to be independent, to make and maintain friendships and relationships, to live independently?

What are these competencies and capacities?  They are not degrees or GCSEs or qualifications of any kind.  They are things that develop unconsciously as part of the natural interaction between child and caregiver in the early years……the interpersonal engagement (reciprocal back and forth between two people) that Peter Hobson has called ‘The Cradle of Thought’.  To understand more about what’s going on here, we need a whistle-stop tour of child development.  I’ll leave that to someone far more qualified than me, Dr Steve Gutstein:

In typical development, ‘infants at around 6-7 months begin to show signs of an insatiable drive to grow…to stretch, learn and explore. Parents, in turn, are instinctively ready to promote this growth and eagerly provide opportunities for the child to explore.

For infants with autism or other developmental challenges, it’s a different story. Their growth-seeking drive doesn’t develop at this time and, instead, the drive for stability becomes their norm. Instead of venturing out, these kids shrink back, shy away and pull in. Consequently, they disengage from their parents who are intuitively trying to provide activities for growth.’  

The whole intuitive interface between growth-seeking infant and growth-opportunity-providing adult breaks down.  The vehicle that provides the ‘cradle of thought’ has gone and children then miss milestone after milestone in a domino effect that eventually lands them in a Paediatrician’s clinic undergoing an ADOS assessment.

The milestones that are missed are those relating to using the thinking of other people to decide what to do when faced with uncertainty.  They are the milestones that facilitate emotional self-regulation, social reciprocity, self-actualisation, social understanding.  These are the milestones that underpin the competencies that lead to making and maintaining friendships and relationships, securing meaningful employment and living independently.

Now don’t get me wrong here – I know some adults with autism who have worked extremely hard to teach many of these competencies to themselves……but what a Herculean effort to have to make to do something that (most!) typical people can do without even having to give it a second thought.  People with autism have described this to me, saying it’s like having to operate in first gear when everyone else is cruising along in 5th.  How utterly exhausting.

Missed milestones.  Missed……..milestones.  

Do we know what these milestones are that children with autism and other developmental difficulties fail to master (or only master in part)?  Yes we do.  Do we know how these milestones are mastered?  Yes, we do. (I appear to have started channeling President Obama).

Can we help our kids and adults with developmental challenges (and regardless of any LD) to have another go at mastering these milestones……those of you who follow my blog regularly know that I am blogging on an ongoing basis (with video footage and commentary) about how this is done in one particular school and about how many parents around the world are doing it with their infant, teen and adult children.  Some of what these older folks are now able to do include the abilities to:

  • See different ways they might approach challenging situations
  • Imagine productively
  • Infer what others are feeling and thinking
  • Generate multiple possible ways of responding to a challenge
  • Use feelings in a productive way to make judgements when the environment is too complex
  • See decision-making as a process where we balance different variables

The best part is that they can do all of that reflexively – subconsciously – so they are not having to perpetually operate in 1st gear.  They can respond more adaptively when faced with challenges that would previously have activated their ‘fight or flight’ response.  This has enabled them to live more #ordinarylives because they are no longer withdrawing from uncertainty, novelty and change…..they are embracing it, enjoying it and even seeking it out.

Di’s son Nick, now nearing 20 years of age, has autism and LD.  Here, Di writes about how, following many years of hard work helping Nick to master these milestones, he 'cruises along and takes life in his stride’.  (I promise we didn’t collaborate on the driving metaphor). She notes how ‘He doesn't need a rigid schedule and he remains relaxed if I need to change our plans. It's fabulous to have a flexible teen. The stress we lived with in the early days is now a distant memory.’ 

My own son has gone from using what would be described in professional circles as controlling, oppositional, demand-avoidant behaviour to being a much more socially reciprocal, thoughtful, flexible, self-aware young man who is genuinely interested in other people, can take on board and use their perspectives in a discussion instead of being on his own agenda and is much better able to regulate his own emotions when faced with challenges.  He also helps me to regulate when I get overwhelmed or frustrated.  Right now, he is out with his friend (his friend!!) - a recent development (he is 16 years old).  They are walking the dog and I am welling up just writing that. #ordinarylife 

It’s taken us 10 years and it has been hard work (same for Di and Nick).   We have done it with everyday stuff as the vehicle for our ‘cradle of thought’.  Our vehicle ‘stuff’ included things like loading the dishwasher, putting the washing out, playing games, baking and cooking……LOTS of baking and cooking, which is why my blog is called ‘Food for Thought’. 

I was not the teacher.  Nothing was scripted or formally taught….we just hung out together and had fun.  We both learned an enormous amount and our mother and son bond is now very close.

We still have a long way to go but I am now quietly confident that my lad has got some of the foundational competencies and capacities he needs to allow him to live at least a semi-independent and fulfilling life.  We will keep working on mastering missed milestones.

I have written in the past about my view that we need to be supporting people with developmental challenges in all settings (not just education) to master missed milestones.

A few years back, I attended the National Autistic Society’s Annual General Meeting where I met a 64 year old fella with Asperger’s syndrome who, I discovered, lived near me. I gave him a lift home and on the way he told me about his life. He said that because his parents did not understand him, he had often been ‘farmed out’ to relatives; school had been ‘a nightmare’ and he had had pervasive difficulties holding down a job (despite a MENSA level IQ); he had got into a terrible financial tangle because he didn’t understand anything about money unless it was cash, and he had missed out on two opportunities he identified (with hindsight) as potential relationships because he couldn’t read the signals at the time.  

My friend identified his biggest lifelong challenge as the difficulty he has responding adaptively to the myriad of interpersonal challenges related to navigating the world on a day-to-day basis.  

Another adult with autism who is a research associate at the University of Maine wrote that ‘social encounters are dynamic occurrences that require spontaneity, flexibility, and adaptation’. 

All encounters, in every sphere of life, are social encounters. Such adaptation is often required on a moment-to-moment basis and it is these difficulties with simultaneously processing lots of information from multiple channels as it changes on a second by second basis that are one of the most difficult challenges for those with autism.

General awareness about autism and support services for people with autism have undoubtedly improved since some of my friend’s earliest experiences, but the principles that drive the provision of health, education and social care services for people with autism (with or without LD) in this country have not moved very far at all in the last 40 years. Cutting edge research into the brain, autism and child development is giving us a clear message about what can be achieved for people with autism, yet despite this, our services are still compensating for the difficulties resulting from autism instead of addressing them.

The mainstream response to the anxiety resulting from difficulties coping with uncertainty in children and adults with autism has historically been to adapt the environment so that uncertainty is minimised and to entrench people with autism in the predictability of routines. In some ways, it is an understandable response, as predictability decreases anxiety, but the consequence is that we amplify reliance on routines instead of helping people with autism to develop the ability to produce a more adaptive range of responses and remove the need for a ‘fight or flight’ response.

Those who follow my blog will know that the school I mentioned earlier on in this post is Bright Futures School, which me and hubby set up specifically so that we could embed a social communication programme into the curriculum.  The social communication programme is what we use to work on the missed milestones.

It is my firm belief that a social communication programme is crucial for every child with autism and other developmental challenges in an educational setting and that it should be provided via Education, Health and Care Plans.  The need for social communication programmes of this type is even recognised in the NICE guidelines ‘Autism in under 19’s:Support and Management’ 

I am currently working on devising a model EHC Plan that clearly outlines social communication needs and includes social communication provision in each of the sections relating to education, health and social care and am in discussion with my local authority about exactly what this should look like.  I intend to anonymise it and share it as soon as it’s finally agreed.

In the meantime, if your child or young person hasn’t yet got an EHC Plan, please have a look at this.

If you want to have a look at a social care assessment (children) that identifies social communication needs, have a look at this.

If you would like to investigate making a legal case for social communication provision to be included in an EHC Plan, have a look at this

Prevention is better than cure.  Let’s use those EHC Plans to get the right provision and support in place that will enable us to keep our kids out of ATUs and enable them to develop the competencies and capacities that will allow them to have #ordinarylives as much like those of their siblings and peers as possible.


Saturday 23 April 2016

#7Daysofaction: Using the power of the pen


#7Daysofaction started on Monday 18th April 2016.  The campaign has been launched by the mothers and family members of people with learning disabilities (and often, autism) who are currently trapped in Assessment & Treatment Units (ATUs).

These people have committed no crime but in many cases (read the stories in the links below) they are treated worse than criminals. Some have died as a result of neglect and poor care in state funded institutions.  Most have not been diagnosed with a mental health condition, yet are detained under the Mental Health Act and they remain in Units for years at a time.  

The Mental Health Act is one of the villains in this sorry tale because it defines autism and learning disabilities as ‘mental disorders’ and this is one of the things that contributes to people getting stuck in the system.

There are currently 3000 people in ATUs and the average cost of being kept in an ATU is £3500 per week…..yes, per week.  That’s your tax spondulas right there.  All these detained folk want is to be living back home with their families or living in their own homes with support.  They just want an #ordinarylife.

Click here to read about Robert, Stephen, Tianze, Thomas (a harrowing story particularly close to my heart), Jack, and Eden, with P’s story tomorrow.  And as well as Thomas, let’s not forget Connor Sparrowhawk, Nico Reed and Stephanie Bincliffe, who all died preventable deaths in ATU-type provision and whose families are still awaiting justice.

The current situation

There have been plenty of reports and inquiries and Concordats and breakfast meetings and questions in the House about what to do about this national scandal………the fact that we are yet to see any meaningful change is extremely frustrating.

I guess we just have to keep doing what we can.  Some of the families are in discussions with top legal bods about a group legal action, using the Human Rights Act on the basis that the Mental Health Act treats people with autism/learning disabilities differently than others without justification.  This would set an exciting legal precedent, if successful.  It gives me great hope.

One thing those of us not directly affected can do is to use the current statutory framework for service provision to make sure that our own local Commissioners are doing what has been recommended at a national level.

which has been developed with the help of people with lived experience, clinicians, providers and commissioners, and which sets out the range of support that should be in place no later than March 2019. 
Reading through the first document, I noted that 6 ‘fast track’ areas drew up plans in Summer 2015 and according to ‘Building the Right Support’, are ‘already making a difference on the ground.’ Hmmmmmm……………

The 6 fast track areas are: Greater Manchester; Lancashire; North East and Cumbria; Arden, Herefordshire and Worcestershire; Nottinghamshire; Hertfordshire.  I live in Greater Manchester and so took the opportunity to ping the letter below off to the Commissioner who is responsible for fast tracking everything in Greater Manchester.

I would strongly recommend that anyone else who lives in one of these fast track areas writes something similar to their responsible Commissioner.  Please feel free to plagiarise my letter to your heart’s content and let’s see what happens……

Citywide Commissioning & Quality


Re: Transformation of services for people with autism/LD

In the national plan to modernise care ‘Building the Right Support’ it states that 6 ‘fast track’ areas drew up plans in Summer 2015 to shift money into community services in order to reduce their usage of inpatient provision by approximately 50% over the coming three years.  I understand that Greater Manchester is one of these ‘fast track’ areas.

I would appreciate it if you could provide answers to the following questions:
  • How many people from which Greater Manchester areas with autism and/or learning disabilities (LD) are currently placed in which out of area ATUs or similar institutional care facilities?
  • How are Commissioners in Greater Manchester extending the offer of statutory and non-statutory advocacy to people with autism/LD who are leaving a hospital setting?
  • I note from the NHSE ‘service model’ that recommendations have been made to ‘risk stratify’ each local population of people with LD and/or autism and would like to know how this risk stratification is to take place within each relevant area?
  • How is this risk stratification co-ordinated with what is known from information available through EHC Plans?
  • Please can you point me to the public web sites for the GM CCGs that give details of the Local Offers covering the expanded use of personal health budgets?
  • Who are the local ‘care and support navigators’ for Oldham and Tameside?
  • How are the needs of people with LD/autism being planned into housing strategies that enable people to live as independently as possible rather than in institutionalised settings?
  • I understand that there are to be six local crisis beds and an in-reach/outreach team providing safe, short, intensive support when needed.  Where will these beds be located and what will be the nature of the intensive support?
  • I also understand that as part of the Greater Manchester Public Sector Reform Programme, there will be a formal evaluation assessing the impact of the improvement plan over 18 months.  What will be the success criteria for this evaluation and who will undertake it?

I look forward to hearing from you shortly.

I got this response by email on 12.4.16:

‘I will share with my LD and PHB leads and look to draft a response back to you very shortly.’

As I was getting to the end of drafting this blogpost, the Labour candidate who is standing in the upcoming local election in May called at our door. So there I am on a Saturday morning standing in my dressing gown, holding the dog, complete with bedhead, giving the candidate chapter and verse on people with autism and LD trapped in ATUs and asking her what she will be doing to ensure the Greater Manchester-wide plans are properly implemented locally.

That interaction reminded me that I have the shadow Minister for Disabled People as my MP.  I think it’s time I paid her a visit.....

Saturday 16 April 2016

7 Days of Action: The ATU Scandal

After the Winterbourne View scandal in 2011 the government pledged to close all Assessment and Treatment Units (ATUs) by 2014 but there are still 3000 people living in these institutions, sometimes hundreds of miles away from their families.

Can you imagine living a day in a place they call a 'unit'? Here's the story of Eden Evans who's lived in one of these 'units' for 7 years.  Connor Sparrowhawk, Nico Reed, Thomas Rawnsley and Stephanie Bincliffe died preventable deaths in these institutions.  There was no 'assessment' and no 'treatment'.....other than dreadful abuses of human rights.

Get involved in 7 days of action, which starts on Monday 18th April 2016.

Read and follow the blog The ATUs Scandal.

Join the Facebook group.

Share the stories - on social media, verbally, send the links to people you know.

Sign the petitions.

Contact your local press and media.

Lobby your MPs.

Write to your local commissioners.

Discuss how to stop family members being sent to ATUs.

Learn your Mental Health Act & Mental Capacity Act to stop this happening to your family members.

Support the families’ legal action.

Can you offer lifts to families who have hundreds of miles to travel to visit their loved ones?

Can you offer overnight accommodation if you live near to any of the ATUs?

If you can help, get in touch via the ATU Scandal blog.


     Connor (LB)